arrow_back_ios Back View more articles
The Milburn report rightly puts young people locked out of education, employment and training at the heart of the UK’s growth agenda — but its success will depend on whether government, employers and education providers can turn ambitious recommendations into real opportunities, says Matt Tudge of Business West

Milburn: Youth, growth, and the importance of opportunity – Business West

The Milburn report rightly puts young people locked out of education, employment and training at the heart of the UK’s growth agenda — but its success will depend on whether government, employers and education providers can turn ambitious recommendations into real opportunities, says Matt Tudge of Business West.

The much-anticipated Milburn report has been released, six months after the interim report set out the scale and scope of the problem.

It makes wide-ranging recommendations on how we should respond to the challenge of young people not in education, employment or training, or ‘NEET’ – a term I’m not particularly fond of.

Neither, it seems, are some of the young people involved in the review, with one suggesting they are better described as ‘DEET’: desperate for education, employment or training.

The report recognises that this is not simply a skills or employment support issue. The key to addressing it, as with many wider societal challenges, is growth and economic certainty, a mission Business West has been championing for over 200 years.

It is also encouraging to see the need to create new entry-level jobs placed front and centre. Our narrative in skills has long been that we need to focus simultaneously on the demand side of the equation.

The fragmentation of the skills system is another longstanding issue we have been addressing. We are pleased to see the report state explicitly that ‘the system is not a system at all’.

There is much more to do to align the variety of organisations, initiatives and support available. This is something the areas we work in are looking towards through devolution, whether already having Strategic Authority status or working towards it.

The interim report estimated that getting all 18–24-year-olds currently outside education, employment or training into full-time work could add £38bn to the UK economy each year, with longer-term impacts taking the overall economic cost beyond £100bn.

We need to ensure businesses recognise the value of providing opportunities and are supported and incentivised to do so, rather than feeling penalised for taking on responsibility.

The final report acknowledges this, proposing financial incentives for employers taking on young people who have been out of work, alongside changes to employers’ National Insurance costs for younger workers in retail and hospitality.

But we cannot ignore that the cost of recruiting young people has increased significantly in recent years, driven by rises in National Insurance, minimum wage and inflation. Employers have also argued that changes to the National Insurance threshold have damaged some traditional routes into work, including first-step and part-time jobs.

Most business decisions involve an implicit risk-and-reward calculation, and entry-level employment has changed considerably. Consumer habits, disposable income, the cost of living, automation and the impact of the pandemic have all altered traditional routes into work, likely for the long term.

But people still need human connection and interaction alongside goods and services. We need to ensure changing markets and business models continue to create opportunities for people to start their careers.

We cannot ignore the increased costs and perceived risks of recruitment. We need to incentivise businesses to provide opportunities while recognising the value of young people beyond immediate financial return.

Further education is already doing a great deal of excellent work. We should concentrate less on asking education providers to do more in isolation, and more on alleviating the concerns businesses have about recruiting and supporting inexperienced young people.

That does not mean education has no part to play. Learning needs to be connected to employment through greater exposure to industry, a better understanding of careers and opportunities, and course content that reflects the changing world of work.

Milburn’s proposals for a statutory duty on schools to provide work experience, and to assess work readiness alongside attainment and destinations, are welcome. So too is the ambition to make apprenticeships a mainstream destination alongside university.

Initiatives like Colleges West are already working towards devolved structures that can change how we work together as a region. But we must also recognise the contribution of other providers, with around 65% of apprenticeship places delivered through Independent Training Providers.

Regionality and devolution are important. Responses need to be based on local intelligence, employer demand and the specifics of local economies. Devolution provides an opportunity to do this, but we need to consider whether the Milburn report goes far enough in recognising its potential. We need collaborative, responsive systems that address both the long-term interests of an area and its immediate workforce needs.

The proposed local Youth Opportunity Services could help bring organisations together, but their success will depend on whether they simplify the system and make it easier for employers and young people to access support, rather than adding another layer.

Ultimately, we need to raise optimism, understanding and recognition of the benefits of getting more young people into meaningful work across society: parents, teachers, business owners, support organisations and young people themselves.

We all want the same thing: a future in which our area continues to be one of the best places to live, work, learn and thrive. Opportunity, economic growth and skills development go hand in hand. We need to make it easier for everyone to play their part.

Matt Tudge, is head of skills at Business West

South West businesses target £331m AI growth prize

Read more

26.10.2026

New skills plan for West of England launched

Read more

20.08.2026

Colleges and universities formally launch joint forums to boost skills, growth and opportunity

Read more

02.07.2026

Business West presses case for Thames Valley devolution

Read more

02.07.2026

New government-funded tech advice for Wiltshire firms launched

Read more

06.05.2026

Unleashing West of England could power UK’s growth – report

Read more

19.03.2026

Science minister hears how Swindon will play central role in tech boom

Read more

23.02.2026

Building Swindon’s Future will be topic of discussion at Business West event

Read more

27.01.2026

Business Biscuit
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.